Leave a Message

Thank you for your message. We will be in touch with you shortly.

About Sheila Penister

Sheila Penister Montebello, NY Real Estate Agent Headshot

Sheila Penister

Get to Know Me

Sheila Penister, co-owner of Real Property Management DePenn, brings a wealth of experience from her 22-year career as a New York State Parole Officer.

Her extensive work with the public and within the criminal justice system helped her develop valuable skills that translate naturally into the property management profession. Sheila’s calm, level-headed approach enables her to navigate challenging situations with professionalism, sound judgment, and fairness, while complementing Duane’s leadership and experience.

An effective communicator and thoughtful problem-solver, Sheila has a unique ability to quickly assess situations, gather the relevant information, and develop clear, practical solutions. Her steady presence and attention to detail play an important role in helping Real Property Management DePenn provide owners and tenants with responsive, professional, and dependable service.

Testimonials

Hear what our clients have to say about their experience.
Buyer | Seller

Buyer | Seller

Sheila kept me informed of all events during this process. If she didn't have the answer to a question I posed, she would find out the answer and immediately call me. We ended up right in the middle of the pandemic, attempting ...
Read More
Dreena D.

Dreena D.

You can't go wrong in the competent hands of Shiela Penister. She is honest, trustworthy, and a really good person. I have had the pleasure of knowing her for the past 22 years, and she has always displayed the same pleasant an...
Read More
 Andrew S.

Andrew S.

Was able to help select, secure, and move into an apartment in less than a month. Very prompt and professional.
Read More
 Lindsay A.

Lindsay A.

DePenn Realty is a wonderful company! They are reliable and very helpful! Duane helped my family find the perfect rental home! He is always available to answer any of my questions, and he takes the time to make sure he gets bac...
Read More

Start Your Property Search

Browse Homes

What Makes Us Different From the Rest?

At DePenn Realty, we believe real estate is about more than buying and selling properties—it's about building relationships, earning trust, and helping our clients make confident, informed decisions.

With over 20 years of real estate experience, we combine extensive market knowledge with a personalized, hands-on approach that puts our clients' needs first. Whether you're buying your first home, selling a cherished property, or expanding your real estate investment portfolio, we provide the guidance, education, and attention you deserve throughout every step of the process.

What truly sets us apart is our commitment to being your DePenndable Broker—a trusted partner who values integrity, clear communication, and lasting relationships.

Through our affiliated property management company, Real Property Management DePenn, we also offer property owners access to professional management services, providing an additional resource for protecting and maximizing their real estate investments.

At DePenn Realty, your real estate goals become our commitment, and your success is our priority.

Your DePenndable Real Estate Partner.

Follow Us on Instagram